Cart 0 items: $0.00

The Thief

Allan Crum
February 17, 2021 | Allan Crum

Thoughts on Whole Cluster Fermentation & Specs About the Package Wines

Whole cluster fermentation is in, destemmers are out (good riddance, as anyone who has cleaned one will agree), and Henri Jayer is rolling in his grave. We’ve discussed the fickle nature of the wine industry on this blog before. There is always a fresh flavor of funky newness coming over the horizon, or an as yet undiscovered wine region (the enological North Sentinel Island) to be both championed and gate-kept by Magellanic sommeliers. Everyone is drinking rosé again, Cru Beaujolais and the Jura have celebrated their time in the sun, and regenerative viticulture is just now entering the cool-wine zeitgeist.

Whole cluster, though, has managed to pervade both the edgy corners of wine nerd-dom and the pillared halls of wine orthodoxy. There are even large national brands advertising whole cluster fermentation on their labels! Unfortunately, the term is not very well understood, and winemakers have confused the issue further by using several different names for the same process (whole cluster/whole bunch/partially destemmed/etc). We want the truth, the whole cluster truth, and nothing but the truth!

What do you mean by whole cluster?

In a typical red wine fermentation, grape clusters are dropped into a destemmer, which removes the stems and spits out clean purple grapes that look like blueberries. Skip this step, and you are left with full clusters of grapes still attached to the stem. These are whole clusters.

Great, we’ve got whole clusters. Now...uh… how do we make them into wine?

Oftentimes these clusters will be crushed and piled into a fermentation vessel. This crushing can be done mechanically, or through the time-honored tradition of foot-stomping (“pigeage”). This releases juice, submerging the solids, preventing microbial spoilage (also known as vinegar).

That sounds easy! Why would anyone ever use a destemmer?

Well, some varieties are not as well suited to whole cluster fermentation as others. Pinot noir, Grenache, Syrah, Mencía, and Gamay are generally regarded as good fits for whole cluster fermentation, but pyrazine-heavy reds like Cabernet and Merlot can become green and vegetal. Stemmy fermentations also require careful tannin management to prevent hard, unyielding wines. Finally, the potassium in stems (as well as any incidental carbonic maceration) causes the pH of the finished wine to rise, which can lead to instability.

Hey, you tried to sneak in a word there! Think I wouldn’t notice?!? What’s carbonic maceration?

Yeesh. Ok. Carbonic maceration is an intracellular fermentation that takes place in an anaerobic environment, usually a CO2-filled tank. Fruity esters, reminiscent of strawberry and raspberry, are produced, and the malic acid of the grapes is degraded, raising the pH. Uncrushed whole clusters are very conducive to carbonic maceration, and almost all of the classic producers of Cru Beaujolais use whole clusters and at least semi-carbonic maceration. This leads to the fruity aromas and silky textures that the region is known for.

Welp, I’m sorry I asked. Ok, I think I’m getting it. If you’re lazy and you don’t want to use the destemmer, you can use whole grape bunches in your wines. That’s whole cluster.

Well, mostly. Remember, a winemaker doesn’t have to leave his entire harvest as whole bunches. Many winemakers will choose to either destem part of a crop or fill a fermenter with alternating lasagna layers of destemmed grapes and whole clusters or destem the whole crop and then add back in some of the de-graped stalks. Domaines in Burgundy will often vary the amount of whole clusters from vintage to vintage, with a poor or rainy vintage usually getting less while a warm solar vintage gets more. It’s just another wrench in the winemaker’s toolbox.

So, whole cluster usually means not de-stemming grapes, except when it doesn’t. Got it. Very clear cut. Thanks for all your help. What do these Schrodinger wines taste like? Both wine and not wine at the same time, until you drink them?

*Oblivious to sarcasm* You’re very welcome. They taste delicious! Yes, sometimes they can be a little...ahem…stalky, but in the hands of a sensitive winemaker, stems can add lift, spice, and resinous snap. The best way to understand the impact of stems is to try two different wines, one whole cluster and one destemmed, from the same producer or region. Maybe try a rustic, spicy, whole cluster Cornas next to a suave, fudgy, destemmed Hermitage. Ask your local wine purveyor to help you pick out a wine with whole clusters and see what all the cool wine kids are excited about.


Whole Cluster, Cozy Reds 3-Pack, Shop Here

Castro Candaz Tinto 2019

  • Ribeira Sacra, Galicia
  • Primarily Mencia, with Domingo Pérez (Trousseau), Garnacha Tintorera (Alicante Bouschet), Mouratón, Caiño and Brancellao
  • Organic viticulture
  • 100% whole cluster fermentation in wooden vessels
  • Aged in 500l barrels and foudre
  • Raspberry, red cherry, bergamot

Domaine de la Grosse Pierre Chiroubles “Claudius” 2018

  • Chiroubles, Beaujolais
  • 100% Gamay noir au jus blanc
  • Pink granite
  • 80 year old vines
  • 3800 vines per acre
  • 100% whole cluster, semi-carbonic maceration
  • Fermented 12 days with one pump over per day, native yeasts
  • Aged 11 months in concrete tank
  • Unfined, unfiltered, no SO2 until bottling
  • Blackberry, black cherry coulis, cracked black pepper

Eric Texier Domaine de Pergaud Vieille Serine Brézème 2014

  • Brézème, Ardeche
  • 100% Syrah (Serine)
  • ~90 year old vines
  • Limestone soils
  • Organic viticulture, incorporating no-till and compost tea preparations
  • 100% whole cluster fermentation with submerged cap for 5-7 days
  • Aged 3 years in foudre with no racking
  • No punchdowns or pumpovers
  • Unfined, unfiltered, no added SO2
  • 93 points John Gilman
  • Cassis, smoked brisket, salt-cured olive tapenade

International Chardonnay: Winter Whites 3-Pack, Shop Here

Edi Kante Chardonnay 2016

  • Venezia Giulia, Friuli
  • 100% Chardonnay
  • Clay and limestone
  • Fermented and aged 12 months in old barrels
  • Aged 6 additional months in stainless steel
  • Bottled unfiltered
  • Orange blossom, lemon curd, clove

Dominique Lafon Bourgogne Blanc 2018

  • Burgundy, France
  • 100% Chardonnay
  • Clay and limestone
  • Organic viticulture
  • 20-50-year-old vines sourced from Meursault and Puligny-Montrachet
  • Whole cluster pressed
  • Fermented and aged for 12 months in old barrels, native yeasts
  • Little or no battonage
  • White peach, Meyer lemon, crushed chalk

Crossbarn Sonoma Coast Chardonnay 2018

  • Sonoma Coast, California
  • 100% Chardonnay
  • Hand-harvested at night
  • Whole cluster pressed
  • Fermented and aged in 90% stainless steel, 10% neutral oak barrels
  • Aged 5 months on the lees
  • 92 points JS, 90 points WA, 90 points JD
  • Sliced apple, nectarine, wildflower honey

Rhône or Bust Syrah 3-Pack, Shop Here

Patrick Jasmin “La Chevaliere” 2016

  • Collines Rhodaniennes, Northern Rhône
  • 100% Syrah
  • Decomposed granite and schist
  • Sourced from the plains below Côte Rôtie
  • 100% destemmed
  • 20-22 day fermentation with punchdowns
  • Aged 12-18 months depending on vintage
  • Red plum, bresaola, sandalwood


Equis Equinoxe Crozes Hermitage 2017

  • Beaumont-Monteux, Northern Rhône
  • 100% Syrah
  • Gravel and loam
  • Practicing organic
  • Fermented in wood and concrete with native yeasts
  • Aged in 40hl tronconique wooden vessel
  • Black currant, blackberry, anise seed


Domaine Rostaing Les Lezardes 2018

  • Collines Rhodaniennes, Northern Rhône
  • 100% Syrah
  • Fruit sourced from the northern edge of Côte Rôtie, as well as Tupin
  • Majority whole cluster fermentation for 7-20 days
  • Aged in older barrels, many demi-muid
  • 90-91 points VM, 89-91 points JD, 89-91 points WA
  • Blueberry, allspice, wild boar bacon



Commenting has been turned off.

Want the latest updates?

Subscribe to our newsletter to find out about our events, special offers, and new products.